LOGIN DASHBOARD

    COVID19

    Opinions

    3 MIN READ

    Bring them back

    Brabim Kumar, Samrat Katwal, April 15, 2020, Kathmandu

    Bring them back

      Share this article

    Many stranded at the Nepal-India border are seasonal migrants who ought to be brought back and allowed to work on their farmlands

    (The Record)

    Hundreds of seasonal migrants still lie stranded at the India-Nepal border while rulers in Kathmandu instruct the state machinery to prevent them from entering Nepal. At the same time, president Bidya Devi Bhandari has expressed her concern for Nepalis trapped in Europe, Australia and the US. The newly emerged ruling class dons a communist hat and claims to represent the working class but has proven to be largely unsympathetic to their woes. It seems as though the struggles faced by these Nepali citizens and the cries of protest they and their families have been too feeble to penetrate the hard-shelled hearts of decision makers in Kathmandu.

    While hundreds of people wait to enter Nepal across border points with India, they are just the tip of an iceberg comprising more than two million low wage Nepali laborers earning their livelihood in the neighbouring country. Somewhere in the crumbling corners of India’s massive cities, millions carry the hope that their leaders in Nepal will soften and help them find a way back to their homeland. For this stranded population, which is largely jobless and wageless at the moment, dengue, hunger and police brutality are as probable in their future as death by Covid19. In the midst of this, are their provincial and local governments going to just abandon them? Or is the state going to protect only those who are already settled within the comfort of their homes?

    Measures taken by the government suggest that the coronavirus pandemic is being approached as an urban, transient problem. Subsidies on internet and electricity tariffs, tax deferments, relaxation of bank interests, and food subsidies by the Salt Trading Corporation ease the burden on urban residents and seem more suited to be part of a relief package for flood victims. Even information being shared on social media and other online strategies still fail to reach a population of Nepalis who perhaps need it most.

    The crisis will persist until a suitable vaccine is developed, and that is months, if not years, away. Does this mean that we lock our citizens out of Nepal for months? A lockdown is one of many measures to be taken and provides an opportunity to prepare and strategise for more difficult times. If it isn’t accompanied by other equally necessary measures like rapid mass testing, relief support to the poor and bringing back vulnerable Nepalis stuck at the border, it may bring on another disaster.

    Even though Nepali migrants stuck in India have not been the government’s priority, their strength and resilience is evident in how they have walked hundreds of kilometres, dodged border security, swam across rivers to finally make it back home. Stripped of their income in cities combined with the anticipation of reuniting with family has pushed them further into taking these desperate measures.

    In order to manage the spread of the virus more effectively, it is essential for the government to welcome Nepalis back home. As thousands sneak in through a porous border illegally, there is a higher chance for the virus to spread.

    Additionally, those being referred to as migrant ‘laborers’ are in effect farmers back home. Nepal is still largely a rural country and while political systems have changed, rural, impoverished lives remain the same. For any rural Nepali family from Karnali or Sudurpaschim, farming and seasonal out-migration to India are part of life. It is heartbreaking to see Nepali citizens who are exploited for their labor in India being denied their basic right to return home, waiting instead in a stateless limbo just across the border.

    Cities in India and Nepal have been the go-to destinations for the poorest Nepalis who have neither cash nor the means to obtain passports or pay manpower companies to help them go abroad. They are often seasonal migrants, travelling into cities for work after harvesting and return before planting season. Currently, it is the time to harvest wheat in the Terai, herbs like Yarshagumba in the mountains while rice and millet planting season is soon to approach. To deny entry to migrants who would otherwise be farming back home will only exacerbate food shortages that already exist in regions like Karnali.

    If the ruling class can muster political will, it will not be difficult to facilitate the return of Nepalis. For those stranded in Nepali cities, it is essential to arrange for transportation to help them return home, keeping in mind necessary precautions. Safe and compulsory quarantines at the point of arrival will reduce disobedience and negligence by returnees.

    What will be incredibly unfair and inhumane is to have a scenario where farmers lineup in Indian and Nepali cities to receive food packages as part of relief efforts whereas they could be helping in food production if safely transported back home.

    :::::::::::

    The Nepali version of this article was first published here on 4 April.



    author bio photo

    Brabim Kumar  Brabim Kumar is a young activist, writer from Nepal.



    author bio photo

    Samrat Katwal  No bio.



    Comments

    Get the best of

    the Record

    Previous Next

    YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

    Photo Essays

    1 min read

    Stark, silent

    Laxmi Prasad Ngakhusi - July 24, 2020

    Photographer Laxmi Prasad Ngakhusi's photos of Kathmandu Valley during the lockdown

    Opinions

    6 min read

    What is and isn’t in a word?

    Suresh Bishwokarma - June 3, 2020

    The upper-caste resistance to the term ‘dalit’ shows a refusal to let go of long-standing Hindu caste-based hierarchy

    Explainers

    4 min read

    Workers left in the lurch

    Roshan Sedhai - August 20, 2020

    The govt has callously suspended its campaign to repatriate stranded migrant workers

    Features

    6 min read

    People with disabilities shoulder double the burden during the pandemic

    Obindra B. Chand - April 30, 2021

    Research shows that disabled people are unequally affected during health emergencies, and this phenomenon is particularly acute in low and middle income countries.

    COVID19

    News

    3 min read

    Covid19 Roundup, 17 April : Covid19 cases jump to 30 & more

    The Record - April 17, 2020

    A daily summary of Covid19 related developments that matter

    Perspectives

    4 min read

    Women’s representation and intersectional (un)inclusion 

    Kalpana Jha - March 17, 2022

    Has gender equality actually been achieved or does it only represent a partial shifting of powers from male Khas Arya individuals to women from the same clan? 

    COVID19

    News

    3 min read

    Covid19 Roundup, 16 May: Cases rise to 278 as govt probes Nepal’s first suspected Covid-19 death

    The Record - May 16, 2020

    A daily summary of Covid19 related developments that matter

    COVID19

    Perspectives

    7 min read

    Treated as family but worked like slaves

    Sandhya Sitoula , Kripa Basnyat - June 21, 2021

    In Nepal, and other parts of the world, domestic workers are routinely denied social and labor protection, and with Covid-19, their problems have only gotten worse.

    • About
    • Contributors
    • Jobs
    • Contact

    CONNECT WITH US

    © Copyright the Record | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy