LOGIN DASHBOARD

    Explainers

    5 MIN READ

    Finance minister overstates health sector allocation, makes wrong claim about Nepal’s income tax regime

    Deepak Adhikari, June 10, 2020, Kathmandu

    Finance minister overstates health sector allocation, makes wrong claim about Nepal’s income tax regime

      Share this article

    Khatiwada spoke about the budget allocation for the health sector and income tax rates in Nepal. While talking about the two issues, he made false and misleading claims.

    
            Finance Minister Yuba Raj Khatiwada speaking at a post-budget press conference in Kathmandu on May 29.
    Finance Minister Yuba Raj Khatiwada speaking at a post-budget press conference in Kathmandu on May 29. (The Record)

    This article was originally published in South Asia Check – an independent, non-partisan, non-profit initiative by Panos South Asia, aiming to promote accuracy and accountability in public debate.

    On May 28, Finance Minister Yuba Raj Khatiwada unveiled a budget of Rs 1.47 trillion for the fiscal year 2020/21 in the Federal Parliament. Citing the COVID-19 pandemic, the budget was downsized by 3.8 percent from last year’s 1.53 trillion.

    On May 29, a day after presenting the budget, Finance Minister Khatiwada, who also serves as the government’s spokesperson, held a press conference at the Ministry of Finance in Kathmandu. He spoke about various aspects of the budget during the 45-minute press conference.

    In the course of his presentation, Khatiwada spoke about the budget allocation for the health sector and income tax rates in Nepal. While talking about the two issues, he made false and misleading claims.

    South Asia Check has fact-checked his claims.

    First claim

    “The budget allocation for the health sector this year is up by almost a third. As you see this is my third budget, and during these years the budget allocation for the health sector has doubled. It is a good thing.”

    According to the expenditure estimates of this year’s budget, a total of Rs 115.06 billion has been allocated for the health sector. In 2019-20, this amount was Rs 78.40 billion. And in the fiscal year 2018/19, health sector received Rs 65.34 billion. Khatiwada was right when he said this year’s allocation is a third more than last year’s but he was wrong to claim that the allocation has doubled in the last three years. For this he should have allocated Rs 130.68 billion for the health sector. In other words, he should have allocated an additional Rs 15.62 billion.

    Second claim

    “Our income tax rates are competitive in South Asia. Whether it’s institutional income tax or personal (income tax).”

    We found that the minister’s this claim is also wrong. After a comparative study of income tax rates in South Asia, we found that Nepal’s personal income tax rates are among the highest in South Asia. Personal income tax rates range from 1 percent to 36 percent in Nepal. No other country in South Asia levies a personal income tax of 36 percent.

    In Nepal, an individual with a net annual income of Rs 400,000 needs to pay 1 percent (social security) tax.  The income tax rate is 10 percent on annual income of up to Rs 500,000 and 20 percent on income up to Rs 700,000. A 30 percent tax is levied on personal income exceeding Rs 700,000.

    Read also: Video clip of anti-India demonstration being circulated on social media is six months old

    India does not tax personal income of up to Rs 800,000. Indians pay only 10 percent tax on annual income of up to Rs 1.2 million; 15 percent on income of up to Rs 1.6 million; and 20 percent tax on income of around Rs 1.9 million.

    In Bangladesh, annual income up to Rs 350,000 is not taxable. Income tax is 10 percent on Rs 570,000; 15 percent on income up to Rs 712,000; 20 percent for Rs 855,000 and 25 percent for up to Rs 4.2 million.

    Similarly, annual income of up to Rs 444,000 is not taxed in Pakistan. Similarly, a five percent tax is levied on income ranging from Rs 444,000 to Rs 888,000.

    In Sri Lanka, annual income of up to Rs 300,000 is exempt from tax. The island nation levies a 4 percent tax on an annual income of Rs 391,000. The government charges tax at progressive rates of 8, 12, 16 and 20 percent for each income slab of Rs 391,000. Bhutan recently increased the threshold for income tax relief to Rs 480,000 from Rs 320,000.

    In an article published on news website www.onlinekhabar.com, Rup Khadka, who headed the High Level Tax System Review Commission, set up to recommend reforms in Nepal’s tax system, said Nepal’s income tax rates were among the highest in South Asia. “Nepal’s average personal income tax rate is much higher than any other SAARC (South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation) country. This is not good for the country’s economic growth. The tax burden should be fixed comparatively,” he said, adding, “Since Nepal is a landlocked country with relatively small economy, from the viewpoint of economic development it is not appropriate for Nepal to impose taxes higher than that of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh.”

    After a comparative study of the income tax rates of South Asian countries and based on the comments of a tax expert, we have concluded that Finance Minister Khatiwada’s claim that Nepal’s income tax rates are competitive in South Asia is also false.

    :::::::::::

     



    author bio photo

    Deepak Adhikari  Deepak Adhikari is the editor of South Asia Check, a fact-checking organization.

      



    Comments

    Get the best of

    the Record

    Previous Next

    YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

    COVID19

    Explainers

    5 min read

    Surviving the pandemic as an indigenous populace

    Nyima Gyaltsen Gurung - April 29, 2020

    Already marginalised by the state, the Dolpo people are more vulnerable to the effects of the coronavirus pandemic

    Features

    6 min read

    Gamifying cycling to create a healthier city

    Kamal Raj Sigdel - September 9, 2020

    A green-lifestyle game that rewards its players and protects the planet

    Features

    5 min read

    NCP factions declare a fight to finish as party awaits official split

    Bhadra Sharma - December 22, 2020

    NCP faction names Madhav Kumar Nepal as the party chief to replace KP Oli as Oli expands the party’s central committee by incorporating his loyalists

    Perspectives

    7 min read

    The die has been cast

    Pranaya Sjb Rana - May 2, 2021

    With over 7,000 cases over the past 24 hours, Nepal has crossed the point of no return. The best time to act was yesterday; the second best time is now.

    Features

    5 min read

    With Kulman gone, darkness looms again

    The Record - September 17, 2020

    PM Oli and his backers would like to appoint a new chief at the NEA, but are afraid that would further fan the flames of public anger

    Explainers

    Perspectives

    7 min read

    The devil on one side and a pandemic on the other

    Pranaya Sjb Rana - May 22, 2021

    In choosing political expediency over the pandemic, Prime Minister Oli and President Bhandari have doomed many more citizens to death.

    Features

    9 min read

    How Nepal’s transitional justice mechanisms can be rectified during the third UN Universal Periodic Review

    Ram Kumar Bhandari - January 19, 2021

    In order to deliver justice to victims and their families, the international community must hold all conflict-era rights violators accountable and incorporate victims’ inputs when designing the country’s human rights agenda

    COVID19

    Features

    7 min read

    Lockdown worsens fertiliser shortage

    The Record - September 8, 2020

    For many paddy farmers, using fertilisers this time of year is crucial

    • About
    • Contributors
    • Jobs
    • Contact

    CONNECT WITH US

    © Copyright the Record | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy