LOGIN DASHBOARD

    News

    3 MIN READ

    Govt’s objection to Lipulekh road: strong in tone, weak in effect

    The Record, May 9, 2020, Kathmandu

    Govt’s objection to Lipulekh road: strong in tone, weak in effect

      Share this article

    India’s inauguration of the link road to Mansarovar causes alarm in Nepal, but is a press statement enough?

    (The Record)

    Nepal’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MoFA) has objected to the opening of a new road connecting Dharchula in Uttarakhand to the Lipulekh Pass in Sudurpaschim, urging New Delhi to refrain from carrying out any activity inside Nepali territory. 

    “The Nepal government has learned with regret about India’s ‘inauguration’ yesterday of a link road connecting Lipulekh, which passes through Nepali territory,” MoFA said in a statement on Saturday. According to Nepal, the Sugauli Treaty of 1816 deems all territories east of the Mahakali River, including Limpiyadhura, Kalapani and Lipulekh, as Nepali territory.

    The statement comes a day after India’s Defense Minister Rajnath Singh inaugurated the road via a video conference, dubbing it as the shortest route to Kailash Mansarovar.

    MoFA has reiterated its stance several times in the past. On 20 November, 2019, the most recent diplomatic note addressed to the Indian government responded to a new political map issued by India. According to MoFA’s statement, Nepal has proposed dates for holding a meeting between the foreign secretaries of the two countries twice, but has not received any response from the Indian side. Criticising the unilateral act by India, the statement calls for diplomatic solutions to boundary issues while keeping in mind “the spirit of close and friendly ties between the two countries.”  

    MoFA also stressed on the need to address all outstanding issues documented in a report by Eminent Persons Group (EPG). Currently, the report by EPG, a bilateral mechanism formed to revise various treaties between India and Nepal, remains to be made public due to the unwillingness of the Indian side. The Nepal government has expressed its willingness to implement the report, insisting that it will be in the best interest of both nations to follow its recommendations which will help address outstanding issues and pave the way for even stronger bilateral ties.

    In its choice of words, Saturday’s statement is possibly the strongest from Kathmandu. In 2015, the government had objected to the India-China agreement to include the Lipulekh Pass as a bilateral trade route without Nepal’s consent, and in 2019, to India’s release of a new political map which included disputed territories.

    MoFA’s objection comes at a time when the Oli government is facing growing criticism for remaining oblivious to the construction of the road, especially after having failed to register a strong objection during the release of the 2019 map. On Saturday, the Sajha Party described the inauguration of the road as an “interference on Nepal’s sovereignty and territorial integrity” and criticised the government for remaining but a silent spectator. A group of youth were arrested from the Maitighar Mandala on Saturday for protesting against the Indian government.

    The area around Lipulekh and Kalapani has long remained a disputed territory between Nepal and India, although the Sugauli Treaty signed between Nepal and the East India Company, and treaties signed later with independent India, acknowledge the Mahakali River as the boundary between the two countries. According to Ratan Bhandari, a researcher who has penned a book on Kalapani, Indian troops captured Nepali land during the 1950s, although attempts to alter the map had started much earlier, soon after Nepal and the British Raj unveiled a joint map in 1856. In the present day, India recognises “a sub-stream of the Mahakali River as the borderline.” 

    On Saturday, the parliamentary State Affairs and Good Governance Committee and International Relations and Labour Committee separately summoned Home Minister Ram Bahadur Thapa and Foreign Minister Pradeep Gyawali to be present in a meeting the following day for briefing on the development.

    Read also: The Indian checkposts, Lipu Lekh, and Kalapani

    Many suspect that MoFA’s press statement might be just a tactic to quell domestic pressure instead of a strong diplomatic note.

    “The press release is good! Now expecting a strong diplomatic note with similar tone, together with diplomatic demarches both in Kathmandu and New Delhi,” Madhu Raman Acharya, a former foreign secretary, tweeted.  

    According to Buddhi Narayan Shrestha, an expert on border issues, Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli should immediately hold telephone conversations with his Indian counterpart and ask India to halt all activities until the resolution of disputes.

    Speaking to the Record, Shrestha asserted, “A press statement from an unnamed foreign ministry official is not sufficient. The PM should hold a one-on-one call.”

    ::::::::



    author bio photo

    The Record  We are an independent digital publication based in Kathmandu, Nepal. Our stories examine politics, the economy, society, and culture. We look into events both current and past, offering depth, analysis, and perspective. Explore our features, explainers, long reads, multimedia stories, and podcasts. There’s something here for everyone.



    Comments

    Get the best of

    the Record

    Previous Next

    YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

    Features

    11 min read

    Deaths in custody

    Abha Lal - June 22, 2020

    Patterns of negligence, alleged abuse, and impunity in Nepal Police

    Features

    7 min read

    Fourteen years of silence, fourteen years of pain

    Dewan Rai - February 5, 2021

    The two transitional justice commissions have received a new lease but for victims, that doesn’t mean much.

    COVID19

    Features

    10 min read

    How accurate is Nepal’s Covid-19 death toll?

    Marissa Taylor - February 22, 2022

    According to government data, nearly 12,000 Nepali deaths have been attributed to Covid-19 but poor data keeping and discrepancies call the number into question. 

    COVID19

    News

    3 min read

    Covid19 Roundup, 6 April: Lockdown extended once more, 9,168 quarantined, & docs asked to join public hospitals

    The Record - April 6, 2020

    Daily summary of all Covid19 related developments that matter

    Perspectives

    5 min read

    Bacteria and the Bagmati

    Adarsh Man Sherchan , Sophiya Gyanwali - October 24, 2021

    Bagmati’s wastewater is perhaps the largest biological threat to public health in Kathmandu and as Covid-19 has shown, threats to public health affect everyone.

    Features

    8 min read

    Whether in Nepal or in the US, caste persists

    Pranaya Sjb Rana , Marissa Taylor - February 17, 2022

    Prem Pariyar’s advocacy has shed more light on caste-based discrimination in the US but back home, discrimination continues in Nepali universities and colleges.

    COVID19

    News

    4 min read

    Daily Covid19 Roundup, 31 March: Border problem persists, pandemic fund enhanced by NHRC & ex-king, hospitals deny entry to patients

    The Record - March 31, 2020

    A daily summary of all Covid19 related developments that matter

    Features

    5 min read

    Nepali students in the US tread on thin ice

    The Record - April 28, 2020

    For many, graduations have been postponed as their finances have dwindled

    • About
    • Contributors
    • Jobs
    • Contact

    CONNECT WITH US

    © Copyright the Record | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy