LOGIN DASHBOARD

    COVID19

    Features

    4 MIN READ

    Antigen tests are cheaper and quicker, but less reliable

    The Record, September 22, 2020, Kathmandu

    Antigen tests are cheaper and quicker, but less reliable

      Share this article

    A Chitwan hospital has begun antigen tests, pre-empting the government’s directives

    (The Record)

    Chitwan Medical College (CMC) has become the first institution to start screening for Covid-19 infections through antigen tests by starting even before the government finalised the national antigen tests guidelines. 

    The college has already managed to conduct 500 tests in the past two days, owing largely to the fact that antigen tests deliver results within two hours, according to CMC representatives. In the past, CMC has conducted over 5,000 PCR tests as Bharatpur is one of the eight districts in Nepal with more than 500 active Covid-19 cases. 

    “Antigen tests have both merits and demerits: quick results are a merit, but it is also slightly less sensitive than PCR test. However, we are using the US Food and Drug Administration approved test kits,” said Dr Harish Chandra Neupane, managing director of CMC.

    The government has not officially approved antigen tests yet as public health experts have pointed out the downsides of other similar testing mechanisms such as the rapid diagnostic tests (RDT). Antigen tests are known to be less sensitive than other diagnostic tests, and thus give false negatives, increasing the risk of the spread of the virus. 

    Additionally, experts have also raised concerns about the quality of test kits. Initially, Nepal started screening the Covid-19 infection with RDT test kits. Nepal imported substandard RDT test kits from China only to find that RDT test results were mostly false negatives. In fact, mass RDT testing only contributed to rapid spread of the virus. 

    Nepal identified its first Covid-19 case in January. On Tuesday, the total number of Covid-19 cases reached 66,632, with 18,142 active cases, and the death toll reached 429. Following the RDT fiasco, and under immense public pressure, the government decided to extend PCR tests. However, the government never boosted daily PCR tests to make them truly effective in countering the virus. Average daily PCR tests still hover around 10,000 per day. 

    The government, meanwhile, has been complaining about its depleting resources for the treatment of Covid-19 patients. It started scaling down PCR tests and treatments for Covid patients. Currently, the government is refusing to conduct PCR tests on the diseased, asymptomatic patients, and even on frontline health workers, while agreeing to only cover the treatment costs of those it has ambiguously termed the ‘poor.’ 

    But this decision has increased the risk of the virus’s spread. There are no exact figures to show how many people exposed to the virus have not shown symptoms. However, it is estimated that between 30-70 percent of cases are asymptomatic. By not testing asymptomatic cases, health workers, and the diseased, the government risks another surge in the number of new Covid cases in the days to come. 

    The Ministry for Health and Population (MoHP) argues that the reason for introducing antigen tests was to ensure mass surveillance as the number of Covid-19 cases continues to rise significantly. On September 10, MoHP spokesperson Dr Jageshwor Gautam informed that the ministry had approved antigen tests. He said that the antigen test guideline, prepared by the Health Research Council, would be endorsed with amendments. 

    Dr Samir Kumar Adhikari, joint spokesperson at the ministry, told The Record that the antigen test guidelines have not been finalised yet. “We are still discussing the areas and sectors in which it can be useful,” said Dr Adhikari. However, he was unaware that CMC had already begun the tests. 

    Antigen tests deliver results instantly and are more convenient to use, much like pregnancy tests. They are also cheaper than PCR tests. But at CMC, clients are being charged NRs 3,000 per test, NRs 1,000 more than the government’s rate for a PCR test.

    “What is the point of introducing a less reliable rapid antigen test if it is more expensive than a PCR test?” said epidemiologist Dr Lhamo Sherpa.

    Experts have been stressing on the need to ramp up PCR tests because of their reliability. PCR tests rely on a laboratory technique in determining infections by using a nose or throat swab. The results take time, often days, in Nepal as there are a limited number of labs. They also need trained technicians, which increases their overall cost. But PCR tests, and not antigen tests, are good at picking up low-level infections. 

    “It does not mean that antigen tests are useless. If we can't boost PCR tests, then we must go for antigen tests. It is useful for surveillance,” said Dr Sherpa. 

    Ideally, antigen tests are meant for mass tests at a low cost to assess the spread of the virus in a community. However, there is upto 20 percent margin of error. This means that if someone tests negative, it is advisable they retest themselves through PCR to confirm they aren’t infected.  

    “I want to make it clear that antigen tests are not a replacement for PCR tests. We have to make the best use of what we have got,” said Dr Adhikari.



    author bio photo

    The Record  We are an independent digital publication based in Kathmandu, Nepal. Our stories examine politics, the economy, society, and culture. We look into events both current and past, offering depth, analysis, and perspective. Explore our features, explainers, long reads, multimedia stories, and podcasts. There’s something here for everyone.



    Comments

    Get the best of

    the Record

    Previous Next

    YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

    Features

    3 min read

    To protect inmates from Covid-19, Court orders early release of those vulnerable to the disease

    The Record - September 10, 2020

    The authorities are finally being forced to address corona-related issues in prisons, but they still remain far too crowded

    COVID19

    News

    4 min read

    Covid19 Roundup, 14 May: Cases rise to 246 and Teaching Hospital sealed

    The Record - May 14, 2020

    A daily summary of Covid19 related developments that matter

    Features

    4 min read

    On foot

    Sujan Shrestha , Ayushma Regmi - April 13, 2020

    Hundreds continue to flock out everyday from the joblessness, hunger and desperation that has come to plague their lives during the lockdown.

    Features

    7 min read

    Nepotism continues to flourish under the Oli government

    Bhadra Sharma - August 26, 2020

    Throughout his career, Upendra Koirala has occupied a set of high profile positions by appeasing communist leaders

    Features

    5 min read

    Choking city

    Shuvam Rizal - January 12, 2021

    Kathmandu air pollution will have long-term impacts not just on public health but also on individual cognition and the national economy.

    COVID19

    Features

    3 min read

    Friday’s Covid-19 numbers show the virus is raging in the capital and across the country

    The Record - October 2, 2020

    With people venturing out more, and with the festival season just around the corner, Nepal is staring at even bleaker days in the very near future

    COVID19

    Features

    7 min read

    Exploited abroad, unemployed at home

    Ishita Shahi - March 22, 2021

    Women migrant workers fled abusive conditions to come home, but with no jobs and no savings, many of them are preparing to leave again.

    Features

    11 min read

    Taken for a ride by Pathao

    Roshan Sedhai - January 2, 2021

    One of Nepal’s most popular new companies faces scrutiny, and employee ire, for what many say are exploitative business practices

    • About
    • Contributors
    • Jobs
    • Contact

    CONNECT WITH US

    © Copyright the Record | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy