Explainers
9 MIN READ
Fact-checking viral video clip reading “Students in Butwal stage huge demonstration against India claiming Kalapani and Lipulekh is ours”.
A video clip with Nepali text that reads “Students in Butwal stage huge demonstration against India claiming Kalapani and Lipulekh is ours” is being widely shared on social media.
Several social media users have posted the video clip that shows a large number of students in school and college uniforms marching on the road with Nepal’s national flags and placards. In the clip, the man recording the video, describes the scene, “Students are chanting slogans Lipulekh is ours, Kalapani is ours!” The video was shot from the overhead bridge at Butwal bus park, according to him.
On May 13, many Twitter and Facebook users posted the video clip along with the aforementioned Nepali text. Bhim (Swatantra) Abis, a Twitter user, who identifies himself as a journalist, shared the text and the video clip at 12:11 pm on May 13. The tweet has been retweeted 61 times and replied to 66 times. Tweeter users have reacted to the post in several ways. Some users have reacted to it as a recent event whereas some have raised questions over the video clip’s authenticity and date. Additionally, some users have even accused him of rumor-mongering by posting an old video. The user, whose full name is Bhim Adhikari, has a bachelor’s degree in science and is a web designer, according to his website.
(Left) Bhim (Swatantra) Abish’s Twitter post of May 13 says students in Butwal staged a huge rally claiming Kalapani and Lipulekh belong to Nepal. (Right) Twitter user Dr Baba A’neal Che took screenshots of two tweets before they were deleted.
The tweet was also retweeted with comments by Subhash Ghimire, the editor-in-chief of Republica daily, and Kosh Raj Koirala, a journalist with the same newspaper. Ghimire and Koirala both have deleted their tweets.
According to a screenshot of Ghimire’s tweet, which was posted by Twitter user Dr Baba A’neal Che, Ghimire commented: “Huge protest in Butwal. #Kalapani and Lipulekh issue must be resolved at the earliest. Both the countries need to take steps to calm down the temp and opt for peaceful resolution.” His colleague Koirala went a step further. He retweeted the post with the following comment: “Students ignore COVID-19 & the lockdown. A large number protest against India demanding return of Kalapani & Lipulekh and withdrawal of Indian military personnel in south western town of Butwal. Despite lockdown protests continue in different parts of the country.”
Similarly, several Facebook users have also posted or shared the video clip repeating the claim (See the collage below). A Facebook page called Nepal Music Gallery has also posted the video with the same claim and has already been shared 10,000 times. Similarly, the page Umanga Bajureli’s post has generated 1,100 shares and Namaste Nepal Viral page had been shard 649 times until Friday afternoon.
South Asia Check fact-checked the viral video. We used a web-based application called InVID. The tool turned the video clip into multiple key frames. We conducted a reverse image search of the images on Google. We found that the same video was posted on the Facebook page “Nepal E News” on November 24, 2019. This video was also shared in November last year on many Facebook pages and individual Facebook accounts.
In addition to this, we also found the same video was uploaded on YouTube on November 24, 2019, on a channel called ‘Nepali Man Dekhi’.
News website Setopati had published the news and pictures of the demonstration on November 26 under the headline “Students demonstrate in Butwal against new Indian map”.
It is true that the viral video shows a protest against India over Kalapani and Lipulekh, but it is not a recent video. We found that it is about six months old. Last November, protests erupted in Nepal after India published a new political map by including Kalapani, Lipulekh and Limpiyadhura inside Indian borders. This video was shot around that time and shows a demonstration organized in Butwal.
A few days ago, the Indian government said it inaugurated a strategic “link road” connecting India’s Dharchula with Lipulekh. This has sparked protests in Nepal. Indeed, protesters marched in a few parts of Kathmandu ignoring the ongoing COVID-19 lockdown, but the aforementioned video which is widely being circulated now is actually six months old.
:::::::
This article was originally published in South Asia Check – an independent, non-partisan, non-profit initiative by Panos South Asia, aiming to promote accuracy and accountability in public debate.
A video clip with Nepali text that reads “Students in Butwal stage huge demonstration against India claiming Kalapani and Lipulekh is ours” is being widely shared on social media.
Several social media users have posted the video clip that shows a large number of students in school and college uniforms marching on the road with Nepal’s national flags and placards. In the clip, the man recording the video, describes the scene, “Students are chanting slogans Lipulekh is ours, Kalapani is ours!” The video was shot from the overhead bridge at Butwal bus park, according to him.
On May 13, many Twitter and Facebook users posted the video clip along with the aforementioned Nepali text. Bhim (Swatantra) Abis, a Twitter user, who identifies himself as a journalist, shared the text and the video clip at 12:11 pm on May 13. The tweet has been retweeted 61 times and replied to 66 times. Tweeter users have reacted to the post in several ways. Some users have reacted to it as a recent event whereas some have raised questions over the video clip’s authenticity and date. Additionally, some users have even accused him of rumor-mongering by posting an old video. The user, whose full name is Bhim Adhikari, has a bachelor’s degree in science and is a web designer, according to his website.
(Left) Bhim (Swatantra) Abish’s Twitter post of May 13 says students in Butwal staged a huge rally claiming Kalapani and Lipulekh belong to Nepal. (Right) Twitter user Dr Baba A’neal Che took screenshots of two tweets before they were deleted.
The tweet was also retweeted with comments by Subhash Ghimire, the editor-in-chief of Republica daily, and Kosh Raj Koirala, a journalist with the same newspaper. Ghimire and Koirala both have deleted their tweets.
According to a screenshot of Ghimire’s tweet, which was posted by Twitter user Dr Baba A’neal Che, Ghimire commented: “Huge protest in Butwal. #Kalapani and Lipulekh issue must be resolved at the earliest. Both the countries need to take steps to calm down the temp and opt for peaceful resolution.” His colleague Koirala went a step further. He retweeted the post with the following comment: “Students ignore COVID-19 & the lockdown. A large number protest against India demanding return of Kalapani & Lipulekh and withdrawal of Indian military personnel in south western town of Butwal. Despite lockdown protests continue in different parts of the country.”
Similarly, several Facebook users have also posted or shared the video clip repeating the claim (See the collage below). A Facebook page called Nepal Music Gallery has also posted the video with the same claim and has already been shared 10,000 times. Similarly, the page Umanga Bajureli’s post has generated 1,100 shares and Namaste Nepal Viral page had been shard 649 times until Friday afternoon.
South Asia Check fact-checked the viral video. We used a web-based application called InVID. The tool turned the video clip into multiple key frames. We conducted a reverse image search of the images on Google. We found that the same video was posted on the Facebook page “Nepal E News” on November 24, 2019. This video was also shared in November last year on many Facebook pages and individual Facebook accounts.
In addition to this, we also found the same video was uploaded on YouTube on November 24, 2019, on a channel called ‘Nepali Man Dekhi’.
News website Setopati had published the news and pictures of the demonstration on November 26 under the headline “Students demonstrate in Butwal against new Indian map”.
It is true that the viral video shows a protest against India over Kalapani and Lipulekh, but it is not a recent video. We found that it is about six months old. Last November, protests erupted in Nepal after India published a new political map by including Kalapani, Lipulekh and Limpiyadhura inside Indian borders. This video was shot around that time and shows a demonstration organized in Butwal.
A few days ago, the Indian government said it inaugurated a strategic “link road” connecting India’s Dharchula with Lipulekh. This has sparked protests in Nepal. Indeed, protesters marched in a few parts of Kathmandu ignoring the ongoing COVID-19 lockdown, but the aforementioned video which is widely being circulated now is actually six months old.
:::::::
This article was originally published in South Asia Check – an independent, non-partisan, non-profit initiative by Panos South Asia, aiming to promote accuracy and accountability in public debate.
Features
5 min read
The media’s blind celebration of Gokarna Bista tells us less about him and more about our need for a success story and skewed politics.
COVID19
Photo Essays
3 min read
Covid-19 forced Jaquir Mansuri to cancel his daughter’s wedding and delay his plans for retirement but the pandemic is not over yet and Mansuri has gone back to work.
COVID19
Features
5 min read
The government’s indecision about vaccine imports and trials is going to cost the people dearly
COVID19
Features
4 min read
Prime Minister Oli has pledged to vaccinate all Nepalis in three months but that seems unlikely
COVID19
News
3 min read
A daily summary of all Covid19 related developments that matter
Features
COVID19
3 min read
Of late, the government has become far too lax about Covid-19 protocols
Features
7 min read
With Nepal placed under the ‘red zone’ category by many countries, hundreds of students admitted to foreign universities are worried that they will lose their scholarships and an opportunity of a lifetime.
Writing journeys
13 min read
This week on Writing Journeys, US-based journalist and writer Sanjay Upadhya recounts his time working at The Rising Nepal under the Panchayat and the lessons he’s learned along the way.
