Features
3 MIN READ
The decision to allow Gautam, who came up short in the 2017 elections, to work as a minister will set a bad precedent
After nearly two months of waiting since taking the oath of office and secrecy, senior leader of the Nepal Communist Party (NCP) Bam Dev Gautam has been greeted with some good news: he can now claim a ministerial berth.
A constitutional bench of the Supreme Court led by Chief Justice Choldendra Shumsher JBR on Wednesday paved the way for Gautam to become a minister by scrapping its own previous temporary order. The bench, comprising justices Deepak Kumar Karki, Hari Krishna Karki, Bishowambhar Prasad Shrestha, and Ishwor Prasad Khatiwada, along with the CJ, concluded there was no legal ground to bar Gautam from becoming a member of the Upper House and get appointed as a minister in the near future. And it has been learnt that Justice Khatiwada rescinded his note of dissent regarding the court decision.
“I extend my sincere thanks to all those who supported me and expressed good wishes during this period,” Gautam wrote on his Facebook page. The message was accompanied by a cheerful photo of him with a red tika and jamara on his forehead. “I’m also grateful to all the legal experts who made the defense on my behalf.”
Although he had already been minister several times, Gautam was desperate to ensure his entry into the parliament and get a ministerial position one more time after the NCP garnered a resounding victory in the 2017 parliamentary elections. But his dream--to get a ministerial berth or maybe even become prime minister--was shattered after he was defeated in Bardiya by Nepali Congress leader Sanjaya Gautam.
After his defeat, Gautam attempted to get re-elected from nearly a dozen electoral constituencies. But it was all in vain. And except for Rambir Manandhar, most of his party cadres refused to vacate their electoral constituencies for him. But the party leadership kept trying to bring him into parliament. Owing to the turbulence in the party and in government, the party leaders needed his alliance to go up against others and remain in power.
Initially, the party’s chairman, KP Sharma Oli, was reluctant to name Gautam as an Upper House member. But Oli was forced to recommend him to the Upper House after the PM found himself in the minority within his own party, and Gautam’s support was crucial to save his prime ministership.
After Gautam failed to secure a position in the Parliament’s Lower House, he was appointed as a member of the Upper House under the quota allotted to the President. Shortly after, he was lobbying in the party to get a ministerial berth. At that point, advocate Dinesh Tripathi filed a writ petition demanding that the decision to name Gautam to the Upper House be scrapped, on the premise that a person who had been defeated in the polls shouldn’t be allowed to become minister.
Gautam did not have much time on his hands. Article 78 of the Constitution allows an Upper House member nominated by the President to lead a ministry for not more than six months. And any such member needs to then get elected from a constituency if they want to continue on as minister.
The apex court, which had initially stayed Gautam from working as an Upper House member, however, paved the way to his becoming a minister as well. That order has also provided respite for other NCP leaders who had lost their elections, but who managed to secure their positions in the Upper House by taking advantage of the deepening factionalism in the party.
Apart from Gautam, leaders such as Narayan Kaji Shrestha, Bhagwati Neupane, Bimala Ghimire, and Jag Prasad Sharma, who were defeated in local, provincial, and federal parliament elections were later fielded by the NCP as candidates for the Upper House. They were able to secure their Upper House berths on the basis of indirect votes by the elected people’s representatives at the local and provincial levels. Many observers say there would have been moral pressure against other poll-losing leaders to remain in power if the court had barred Gautam from working as an Upper House member.
And a section of legal experts say the decision to allow Gautam to work as a minister will set a bad precedent for the future. This will essentially encourage the political parties, mainly those leading the government, to reward leaders who were defeated in the polls.
The Record We are an independent digital publication based in Kathmandu, Nepal. Our stories examine politics, the economy, society, and culture. We look into events both current and past, offering depth, analysis, and perspective. Explore our features, explainers, long reads, multimedia stories, and podcasts. There’s something here for everyone.
COVID19
Explainers
3 min read
A message circulating on WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger claims that an Indian student from Pondicherry University has found a cure for COVID-19, and the "home remedy" has been approved by World Health Organization (WHO).
COVID19
News
5 min read
A daily summary of Covid19 related developments that matter
Perspectives
11 min read
The current controversy surrounding the chief justice reflects a broader problem with the judiciary, which is in urgent need of reform.
COVID19
Photo Essays
2 min read
The Nepal government’s announcement of a lockdown threw millions of lives in disarray, perhaps none more so than that of migrant workers looking to return home.
3 min read
The residents of Dalit bastis in Siraha are more worried than the economic implications of the measures taken to contain the coronavirus than about the virus
Features
8 min read
In a Newa village south of Lalitpur Municipality, a community grapples with the prospect of monumental change.
Features
5 min read
Determined to crush Maoist rebels instead of seeking a political solution, Oli is repeating the same mistakes Deuba made in the 90s which resulted in a decade-long people’s war
Perspectives
9 min read
With rising temperatures all but certain, Nepal must focus on a more realistic and comprehensive emissions reduction strategy, strong regional cooperation, and effective global diplomacy.